# 2026-11-13: what the robo rule would have done, 2007 to today

**This is for expectations, not evidence.** The mix, the rule and the checks were pinned and pushed
in commit `de508cf` before this was run, and no pinned value has moved since. A fixed mix has no
edge to prove; the point of the history is to know what an ordinary year, a bad year and a harvest
look like before the live record starts.

Reproduce: `python research/robo_history.py --fetch`. It runs `simulate()`, which calls the same
`decide()` the live sleeve calls, on `config/robo.yaml` as committed.

**Re-run once, after the code review of the same day.** The first run used a rule whose bands were
centred 0.3 points below the spec's table (on the target less the cash reserve, so 54.7% to 64.7%
for US stocks). The review caught the mismatch and the code now matches the table (55% to 65%). The
figures below are from the corrected rule. The first run's are kept in the last section so the
difference is on the record.

## The short version

- **It tracks its own mix closely.** Over 18 full years the rule finished within 0.56 points of its
  yardstick every year (average gap +0.06). The pre-registered limit is 0.75.
- **It trailed SPY in 14 of those 18 years**, by 3.0 points a year on average. The whole of that
  gap is the mix: international stocks and Treasury bills did worse than US stocks over this
  stretch. It is a fact about the last two decades, not a forecast.
- **It falls with the market.** The worst fall was 52.7% (October 2007 to March 2009), against
  55.2% for SPY. Nothing in the rule softens that, by design.
- **It barely trades.** Fifteen rebalances in 19.5 years, moving about 5% of the account in a
  typical year.
- **Tax-loss harvesting pays early or not at all.** All 19 harvests fell in 2007 to 2009, right
  after the simulated purchase. In 16 of 18 full years there were none, including the 2020 and 2022
  falls, because by then the funds were far above what was paid for them.

## The numbers

Window 2007-06-01 to 2026-11-13, one trade a day at the close, 1 basis point each way.

| | Per year | Volatility | Worst fall |
|---|---|---|---|
| Robo rule | 8.1% | 17.9% | −52.7% |
| Its yardstick (60/30/10, rebalanced daily, no costs) | 8.0% | 18.0% | −52.7% |
| SPY | 10.5% | 19.7% | −55.2% |

| Year | Robo | Yardstick | Gap | SPY | Robo − SPY | Rebalances | Harvests |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2007 (from June) | −1.4% | −1.0% | −0.35 | −3.7% | +2.4 | 1 | 4 |
| 2008 | −35.3% | −35.3% | −0.05 | −36.8% | +1.5 | 2 | 12 |
| 2009 | +29.3% | +28.9% | +0.40 | +26.4% | +2.9 | 2 | 3 |
| 2010 | +13.9% | +14.2% | −0.28 | +15.1% | −1.1 | 1 | 0 |
| 2011 | −3.5% | −3.7% | +0.17 | +1.9% | −5.4 | 0 | 0 |
| 2012 | +15.5% | +15.5% | −0.03 | +16.0% | −0.5 | 1 | 0 |
| 2013 | +23.8% | +24.0% | −0.17 | +32.3% | −8.5 | 1 | 0 |
| 2014 | +6.1% | +5.9% | +0.15 | +13.5% | −7.4 | 0 | 0 |
| 2015 | −1.0% | −0.9% | −0.12 | +1.2% | −2.3 | 0 | 0 |
| 2016 | +9.3% | +9.2% | +0.02 | +12.0% | −2.7 | 1 | 0 |
| 2017 | +21.2% | +20.9% | +0.31 | +21.7% | −0.5 | 1 | 0 |
| 2018 | −7.3% | −7.3% | −0.07 | −4.6% | −2.8 | 0 | 0 |
| 2019 | +25.2% | +24.9% | +0.23 | +31.2% | −6.1 | 0 | 0 |
| 2020 | +17.0% | +16.4% | +0.56 | +18.3% | −1.3 | 3 | 0 |
| 2021 | +18.1% | +17.9% | +0.24 | +28.7% | −10.6 | 1 | 0 |
| 2022 | −16.2% | −16.3% | +0.04 | −18.2% | +2.0 | 1 | 0 |
| 2023 | +20.7% | +20.9% | −0.14 | +26.2% | −5.5 | 0 | 0 |
| 2024 | +16.4% | +16.2% | +0.21 | +24.9% | −8.5 | 1 | 0 |
| 2025 | +20.0% | +20.4% | −0.34 | +17.7% | +2.3 | 0 | 0 |
| 2026 (to 11-13) | +10.6% | +10.6% | +0.03 | +11.5% | −0.9 | 0 | 0 |

The first rebalance in 2007 is the initial purchase.

## Reading the pre-registered checks against this

| Check | Limit | In this history |
|---|---|---|
| Return fidelity | within 0.75 points a year | worst full year 0.56 (2020) |
| Rebalancing turnover | under 50% a year | worst year 22.1% (2020, three rebalances), average 5.5% |
| Buys of a locked fund | zero | zero, across 19 harvests |

None of the limits was set from these figures, and none is changed by them. The fidelity limit is
neither loose nor tight here: a gap of 0.2 to 0.5 points is normal, because the live rule lets
weights drift inside their bands while the yardstick is rebalanced every day.

## The harvests

The simulated account bought in June 2007, four months before the peak, so it is close to a worst
case for timing and a best case for harvesting. It swapped funds 19 times through the fall, about
once a month per stock class while prices kept dropping, and banked losses worth about two-thirds of
the account in total (measured against the account on each harvest day). At the pinned 24% rate that
is an estimated tax value of 16% of the account, nearly all of it in 2008.

Three cautions on that figure:

- It assumes every dollar of loss can be used. In practice a loss offsets gains first, then $3,000
  a year of other income, and the rest carries forward.
- It is a deferral. The replacement funds were bought low, so their eventual sale has a larger gain.
- After 2009 the count is zero for 17 years. An account that starts in December 2026 harvests only
  if the market falls below where it bought. A flat or rising first year shows no harvests, and that
  is the rule working.

## What this history cannot tell you

- **Whether the mix beats SPY from here.** US stocks led for most of this window; the stretch before
  it went the other way. The mix was chosen so that the sleeve does not need to know.
- **Real harvest frequency.** These prices fold dividends in, so funds look less far below cost than
  a real account's price-only cost would show. Real harvests would come somewhat more often.
- **Mid-morning execution.** The simulation trades at the close; the live sleeve trades at the
  broker's quote around 10:35 ET.
- **The funds before they existed.** VXUS (2011), IXUS (2012) and SGOV (2020) are extended backwards
  with VEU, CWI and BIL, which track the same markets.

## The first run, for the record

Before the band correction the same script gave: 8.0% a year; yearly gap to the yardstick between
−0.42 and +0.44 (average +0.05); worst turnover year 11.4%; the same 15 rebalances on slightly
different dates; the same 19 harvests; the same worst fall; the same 14 of 18 years behind SPY. The
correction moved rebalance dates by 0.3 points of drift and nothing else.
